Leave a comment

The Hobbit: The Desolation of Smaug (2013)

the-hobbit-the-desolation-of-smaug-poster-2Review by-Jarrett Leahy

Because, like so many of us, I’m a fan of the Lord of the Rings trilogy, I was curiously optimistic when it was announced a few years back that after a long, drawn out contract negotiation, director Peter Jackson was on board to create a film adaptation of The Hobbit, the Tolkien prequel novel about the adventures of Bilbo Baggins. I became slightly concerned when it was then announced that they were fleshing out the one book to create three films, and after watching the stale and uninspiring first Hobbit film, An Unexpected Journey, I decided not to see The Desolation of Smaug in theaters during last year’s Christmas holiday release. However, with my unexpected enjoyment of the Amazing Spider-Man 2 and with Desolation of Smaug just recently released on DVD, I was inspired to give this franchise reboot a second chance. An hour or so into movie, however, I wholeheartedly regretted that decision.

One of the biggest things I’ve learned from studying the truly successful film critics is, they didn’t become truly successful by telling other people their feelings about a particular movie are wrong. So if you’ve been entertained by these Hobbit films, I really am happy for you. Finding enjoyment in the movies we watch is why we love this hobby so much. However, my utter frustration with this latest film almost caused me to pass on putting together a review. But after a couple of days to let it all digest, I felt skipping it would defeat the purpose of this site, which is to share sincere thoughts and observations about the movies we are watching.
THE HOBBIT: THE DESOLATION OF SMAUGFair or unfair, The Hobbit trilogy is and always will be compared to its predecessor, Lord of the Rings. Watching Lord of the Rings, there’s little doubt that filmmaker Peter Jackson put his heart and soul, his blood and sweat into those films, and that love and passion truly come across on screen. This was obviously his baby, and we were in awe of what he was able to create and felt honored to be able share in it. Unfortunately, that same love and passion just don’t seem to be present with The Hobbit films. I don’t know why, but it almost feels as if Jackson is simply going through the motions. The artistry and virtuosity that were shown throughout the first trilogy have instead been replaced by an absurd overuse of CGI. There were times I felt like I was viewing a video game as apposed to a film. The biggest illustration of this was a scene involving the dwarfs floating in barrels down a raging river. The computer graphics used to create that scene were so flagrantly obvious that at no point would my eyes allow me believe that any drop of the water depicted was in fact even remotely real.
hobbit-dwarves-barrels1bAnother glaring example where CGI was used to cut corners was in the creation of the Orcs. I know for those who haven’t seen any of these films the statement I will make about a mythological fantasy creature will be hard to understand, but the Orcs in Lord of the Rings were truly more realistic. Examining the comparison pictures posted just below, you can see through the extensive use of Hollywood make-up, the facial details of the top Orcs are distinctly grotesque. It’s almost as if you can see and smell the funk coming off these beasts, which adds to their fear factor. When compared, even though I can’t imagine how long and arduous it was for the graphic artists to create these images for the film, the computer generated creatures in Desolation just feel like phony, inferior replacements. The skin appearance is too smooth; there isn’t that same meticulous attention to the minute details that the previous make-up artists were able to generate. That awe-inspiring artistry is again missing.
orcsOne of the most important aspects when it comes to these types of adventure fantasies is you have to care about the protagonist and central characters you are going on this journey with. Lord of the Rings succeeded wildly at this. I was truly emotionally invested in the well being of Frodo, Sam, Arogorn, Gimli, and Legolas as they tried to save Middle Earth. Now, perhaps this statement is more of an indictment of me than the film, but I find the dwarfs to be annoying and, frankly, I just don’t care about the character of Bilbo. Martin Freeman’s unhurried, almost detached delivery of the character may work for some, but for me he lacks the personality or on-screen charisma to lead such a large franchise.

I understand cliff-hanger endings are part of the bag of tricks at the disposal of a filmmaker. But to spend two and half hours plodding along with this repetitive and stale storyline only to have the film end the way does I personally found exasperated my frustrations with the film. After my displeasure for The Unexpected Journey, I’m almost shocked to say that I have even less appreciation for The Desolation of Smaug, but it is unfortunately true. Now the final question that remains is, since I’m already two thirds into this distressingly middling trilogy, do I dare waste my time with the last film, The Battle of Five Armies, which is scheduled for release in December?-JL

Grade: D

Edited by-Michelle Zenor
Leave a comment

The Amazing Spider-Man 2 (2014)

the_amazing_spider_man_2_banner_frontReview by-Jarrett Leahy

 As the many obligations that come with being Spider-Man begin to encroach more and more into his personal life, Peter Parker struggles to reconcile his feelings for his girlfriend and the promise he made to her father just before he died to keep her away from danger. To complicate things further, Peter is still trying to come to grips with and find answers as to why his parents abandoned him as a child. When a rekindled acquaintanceship with old friend Harry Osborn goes sour, unforeseen consequences begin to unfold. With the sudden emanation of Electro, a villain whose unprecedented powers far exceed that of Spider-Man, not only are Peter’s loved ones put in danger, but the whole city of New York.

Please allow me to open this review with an admission: I hated the first Amazing Spider-Man. HATED it! In fact, if you were to click on my Steamers section, you’d find The Amazing Spider-Man listed as one of my selections for 2012. The only reason I went to see The Amazing Spider-Man 2 was to put together this review for AmateurCinephile. To be completely honest, I walked into the theater for my matinee showing with every expectation of not liking it, and for the first hour or so there was little put up on screen that changed those feelings. Then something happened. I could literally feel my hesitancy and skepticism begin to melt away as I was sucked into a story that I must confess was at times overly exorbitant. By the end, though admittedly flawed, I walked out of the theater pleasantly surprised by what I saw.
SPDM_1Filled to the brim with bright, flashy CGI, The Amazing Spider-Man 2 is the visual antithesis of the ominous and brooding Dark Knight series. Some of these CGI laden sequences, like the battle scenes between Electro and Spider-Man, were quite impressive. Others, like the opening plane flight scene, were unfortunately a head scratching mess. Overall, I found that the good outweighed the bad when it came to film’s action sequences. However, if I can make one plea to all future directors of superhero films, please, PLEASE stop having citizen bystanders cheering behind meager metal guardings like lobotomized sacrificial lemmings. It’s an eye-rolling cliché that desperately needs to stop.
Emma-Stone-Andrew-Garfield-The-Amazing-Spider-Man-2-INF-2-600x450At times obnoxiously snarky, other times coming off like a hackneyed, grinning goon, Andrew Garfield remains the weak link of this franchise reboot. Luckily for us the powers that be were smart enough to bring in a gifted supporting cast to help make up for what Garfield lacks as a leading man. Front and center among these supporting players is Emma Stone. While Garfield might be playing the title role, it is in fact Stone who is the true star of The Amazing Spider-Man 2. Her radiant charisma and alluring magnetism on screen is intoxicating. You simply can’t take your eyes off of her. And when sharing scenes, Stone is able to bring out the best in Garfield thanks in large part to a sincere and charmingly loving chemistry shared between them. Despite my reservations about him, I will be the first to admit the real life relationship shared between these two young actors certainly helps them when on-screen together. With this being Stone’s last Spider-Man, it’s going to be a daunting task for Shailene Woodley to fill her immense shoes.
emmaOther supporting standouts include 2-time Academy Award winner Sally Field and rising star Dane DeHaan. Field, who plays Peter’s loving guardian Aunt May, brings an assured strength and quiet fortitude to her role. DeHaan perfectly captures the outward brash yet inner turmoil of young billionaire, Harry Osborn while also fully embracing the frenetic and maniacal persona of his alter ego Green Goblin. In comparison, I found Jamie Foxx’s performance to be a mixed bag. His portrayal of obsessive loner Max Dillon was unfortunately a bit too hokey and exaggerated, but once transformed into Electro, I was surprised at how much I enjoyed Foxx’s snarling delivery.
The-Amazing-Spider-Man-2-ElectroThe Amazing Spider-Man 2 suffers from the studio’s choice to stuff it with a superfluity of villains. Academy award nominee Paul Giamatti seemed to be treated like an afterthought, as his wacky performance of Aleksei Sytsevich felt as if it were some sort of last minute throw in. Saying that, I’m shocked to admit that, carried by Emma Stone’s beguiling performance, this second installment from director Marc Webb is a much more satisfactory movie experience than his disappointing first effort. It’s just a shame Stone won’t be around for Spider-Man 3 and 4. (that’s right, there are at least two more of these coming)-JL

Grade: C+

Edited by-Michelle Zenor
Leave a comment

The Invisible Woman (2013)

the-invisible-woman-posterReview by-Jarrett Leahy

At the height of his illustrious literary career, author Charles Dickens was one of the most famed and beloved celebrities in the modern world. While preparing to perform in the play, The Frozen Deep, written by his close friend Wilkie Collins, Dickens is introduced to Nelly Ternan, a would-be actress whose virtuous beauty helps make up for her inadequate acting skills. Dickens, quite taken by Nelly, pursues her companionship despite being married to Catherine Dickens, the mother of his ten children. After some persuasion from her mother, Nelly accepts his advances, becoming Dickens’ secret mistress up until his passing in 1870.

Actors directing films can certainly be a hit-or-miss endeavor. For every George Clooney (Good Night & Good Luck) there is unfortunately an Eddie Murphy (Harlem Nights) or a William Shatner (Star Trek V: The Final Frontier). The Invisible Woman is the second directorial effort from British star Ralph Fiennes, the first being the 2011 Coriolanus, a modern adaptation of the Shakespeare tragedy. Being an admirer of Fiennes’ many talents as an actor, it pains me to be so critical of his efforts as a filmmaker, but there is no way of getting around that The Invisible Woman felt like a drama by numbers. Fiennes spends so much time using every period piece cliché trying to prove to us that he knows how to make a proper drama that he forgets to actually make one.
the_invisible_woman_ralph_fiennes_felicity_jones_2Issues arose almost from the start. During the rehearsal scenes for The Frozen Deep, the use of a hand held camera to capture interactions on stage left me dizzy. Severe light contrasts meant to give the film an aged look instead just cause it to look dark and dingy. Odd jump cuts in the story’s timeline become a distraction, hindering the narrative flow. Fiennes’ overuse and choice of framing for close-ups were also frustrating. Too many times we see Nelly, Felicity Jones’ character, shot on a slanted downward angle, as if the camera were drunkenly looming over her. Other close-ups meant to convey some sort of passionate angst instead came across as some sort of bad 19th century perfume ad. I was seriously waiting for one of the actors to turn to the camera and whisper, “Calvin Klein.”

One of the film’s saving graces is Ralph Fiennes capable performance as Charles Dickens, but unfortunately its impact is hindered by Felicity Jones. Felicity Jones, oh where to begin? Having a spot-on British accent and flawless diction can only take you so far. The sign of a truly gifted actor is the ability to convey a wide range of emotions through just facial expressions. I found myself gazing directly at her, hoping to catch even the slightest nuance of any kind of facial response, only to left staring at an articulate mannequin.
the-invisible-woman-2013-04It’s not an enjoyable thing to write a negative film review, but unfortunately as we all know, not every film succeeds. Hampered by questionable camera shots, lighting choices, along with a dreadfully emotionless performance from Felicity Jones, The Invisible Woman is a disappointing sophomore directorial effort from Ralph Fiennes. How such a lascivious and passionate premise for a film could come off so austere and frigid is beyond me. There is a sultry, scandalous love story in their somewhere. Fiennes just wasn’t able to deliver it.-JL

Grade: D+

Edited by-Michelle Zenor
Leave a comment

The Wind Rises (2013)

The-Wind-Rises-posterReview by-Jarrett Leahy

Ever since he was a young boy, Jiro had always dreamed of flying, but due to his bad eyesight, he knew that would never be a possibility. Instead, he studied everything he could get his hands on about airplane design, becoming one of Japan’s most gifted young engineering students. Upon graduation, Jiro, who was highly sought after, decided to join Mitsubishi, one of Japan’s most prominent engineering companies. With the autonomy to design and create beautiful and innovative airplanes, Jiro became a renowned airplane designer while bringing his home country to the forefront of cutting edge aerial technology.
140219_MOV_WindRises.jpg.CROP.promovar-mediumlargeWhen it comes to Japanese animation, there is no bigger filmmaker than the legendary Hayao Mayizaki. For close to forty years, Mayizaki has been creating some of the finest examples of animated storytelling that are praised not only amongst his peers in the animation world, but throughout all of cinema. Admittedly I’m still a bit of a Mayizaki novice myself, for of the ten feature films he’s created since 1979, I’ve only had the opportunity to see two others, My Neighbor Totoro and Spirited Away. Set largely in the decade leading up to the second World War, The Wind Rises tells the fictional story of Jiro Horikoshi, a character partially based on the famed Japanese aeronautical engineer Jiro Horikoshi, who was in fact the chief designer of many of the aircraft purchased and used by the Japanese military during WWII.
EClREFwWith the complex and delicate nature of some of the film’s subject matter, controversy arose upon the film’s release. Some expressed issues with Mayizaki’s choice to highlight a man who was the main creative force behind so many “killing machines,” while others raised concerns about the film’s glossing over the fact that some of the workers who built Horikoshi’s designs were in fact Chinese and Korean citizens forced into labor by the Imperial Japanese Army. Those concerns are completely understandable, and I wouldn’t dare say those people were wrong for raising them. In fact, I’m glad that they were brought to light. While researching the background story that inspired The Wind Rises, I came across this quotation from Horikoshi’s personal diary on his Wikipedia page that I thought would help better explain where he stood when it came to WWII:

 When we awoke on the morning of December 8, 1941, we found ourselves — without any foreknowledge — to be embroiled in war…Since then, the majority of us who had truly understood the awesome industrial strength of the United States never really believed that Japan would win this war. We were convinced that surely our government had in mind some diplomatic measures which would bring the conflict to a halt before the situation became catastrophic for Japan. But now, bereft of any strong government move to seek a diplomatic way out, we are being driven to doom. Japan is being destroyed. I cannot do [anything] other but to blame the military hierarchy and the blind politicians in power for dragging Japan into this hellish cauldron of defeat.-Jiro Horikoshi

With the country’s immense prosperity since WWII, some forget just how poor Japan was during the first half the 20th century. Many of its citizens struggled to survive, let alone thrive. For eager and gifted engineering students, under the guise of bettering their country, to be given the free rein to dream up and create their own innovative ideas, all while getting paid to do so, I can see how moral lines can quickly become blurred.  What I will say on the subject is the film does try subtly to distance itself from the military aspect with lines such as: “Airplanes are not tools for war; they are not for making money. Airplanes are beautiful dreams; engineers turn dreams into reality,” and, “We’re not arms merchants; we just want to build good aircraft.” There’s even a scene where Jiro mentions he can make his latest plane design lighter and faster if he were allowed to remove the guns, a statement that only elicited uproarious laughter from his bosses and co-workers.
tumblr_mwjeoaH6fG1rqel4ko2_500

Moving away from the film’s underlying politics, The Wind Rises yet again demonstrates Miyazaki’s otherworldly talents as an animator. With sweeping aerial landscapes, breathtaking mountain ranges, bustling ports and waterways, Hayao has created an absolute feast for the eyes. One scene that stands above all others is the truly terrifying depiction of what I later discovered was the Great Kanto Earthquake of 1923. Screaming citizens, buildings lifted and tossed, billowing surges of deadly fire and smoke truly left me in awe of Miyazaki’s ability to capture the shear ferocity of such a calamitous and fearsome event.
The_Wind_Rises_-_'Earthquake'_ClipThe Wind Rises is not all doom and gloom. There is a touching and wistful subplot where Jiro meets and falls in love with a delicate, lovely young woman, highlighted by a beautifully enchanting courtship scene at a mountainous resort retreat. Without saying a word and aided by the lovely musical score, a paper airplane, and a few comical blunders, we witness these two kindred spirits fall deeply for one another. While watching it, I felt like I was watching a scene taken right out of a Charlie Chaplin silent classic.
216473-the-wind-rises-hayao-miyazakiOriginally recorded in Japanese, Walt Disney Studios, the U.S. distributor, recruited some of the finest talent including Joseph Gordon-Levitt, Emily Blunt, Stanley Tucci, William H. Macy, and Werner Herzog to dub the dialogue in English, which allows the viewer to better consume the visual artistry created by this master storyteller. Through the use of an evocative and haunting soundtrack,  Miyazaki has created a fascinating WWII period drama that shows yet again the unlimited possibilities of the animation genre. Despite its initial controversy, The Wind Rises is an exhilarating, magical film experience that arouses a wide range of emotions thanks to its stunning dream sequences, sweeping landscapes, and a heartfelt love story.-JL

Grade: A-

Edited by-Michelle Zenor

 

Leave a comment

2014 Moll Draft

The other day, Michelle introduced to me a film term I had never heard before, the moll. When I asked what exactly a moll was, I was informed that a moll or gun moll was the female companion of a professional criminal. For both Jason and me, one of the most beloved movie genres is the crime/gangster film, and thinking back on our favorites, some of the most indelible and memorable roles would be classified as molls. As we began to come up with a list of our favorite molls, we thought we’d have a little fun and have a moll draft in which we each try to create our best Top 10 performances. Jason was kind enough to give me the first overall pick, allowing him to then have selections two and three; I then had picks four and five, and so on. Surprisingly this goofy idea was kind of fun, so we may do this draft thing again sometime in the future. After you see our selections, be sure to vote on who had the better draft–me of course 😉

543909_428436257222372_1156231955_n (2)JARRETT’S TOP 10   JASON’S TOP 1037746_1321899086919_3333260_n

ROUND 1

round 1
In round 1, there was little surprise in either of our selections. Kay Corleone is the top moll in the ultimate gangster film The Godfather, so I was not going to pass up the chance to have her in my Top 10. Jason’s selection of Mia Wallace was a smart choice on his part, and though it pained me to see her off the board, I suspected I had little chance at landing her.

ROUND 2
round 2

Here in round 2 we had our first surprise choice. I made sure not to mention this prior to our draft, but I had Kay Corleone and Karen Hill ranked numbers 1 & 2 on my draft board, so to say I was excited to see Karen still available after Jason’s choice of Cameron Diaz’s erotically divisive Malkina would be an understatement. I obviously scooped her up with the #4 selection, leading me right into my next selection…

ROUND 3
round 3

I am a huge fan of Badlands and Sissy Spacek, so it was a no brainer that Holly would be my selection in round 3. When I took her, Jason half joked that he was THIS CLOSE to stealing my beloved Sissy just to mess with me.  I must admit if he had it definitely would have worked. Jason responded to my drafting of Sissy with his selection of Charlene Shiherlis, a very underrated moll performance from the lovely Ashley Judd. If she was available a little later in the draft, I would have scooped her up myself.

ROUND4
round 4

Jason’s selection of the lovely Alabama Whitman at pick #7 really cut deep, for we both are big fans of Tony Scott’s crime opus True Romance, and I hoped to pick her at #8. Instead I took the opportunity to grab Ginger McKenna, the crazy, coked out creation of Sharon Stone, which was a nice consolation prize for losing out on Alabama.

ROUND 5
round 5

As much as I like Jason’s choice of Melanie Ralston of Quentin Tarantino’s Jackie Brown, I have little problem admitting that I definitely won round 5 with my selection of the Natural Born Killer herself, Mallory Knox. Booyah!

ROUND 6
round 6

Faye Dunaway’s Bonnie Parker…need I say more?

ROUND 7
round 7

After many rounds of domination, I’m not ashamed to admit that Jason was the victor of round 7 with his selection of the love interest of Butch Cassidy AND The Sundance Kid, Etta Place. However, that’s not to say I regret my choice of Ruth Guthrie. I truly believe Rooney Mara’s moll performance in Ain’t Them Bodies Saints will only grow in appreciation as the film ages.

ROUND 8
round 8

ROUND 9
round 9
ROUND 10
round 10

I will call these last three rounds a push, with each of us choosing some personal favorites. I’d like to point out that, unlike Neil McCauley in Heat, with the last pick of the draft I did not leave Eady hanging. So that’s it ladies and gentlemen, our Top 10 Molls. Feel free to leave any thoughts or your own Top 10 lists, and be sure to vote for your favorite list.

PERFORMANCES BALLOT: Ain’t Them Bodies Saints-Ruth Guthrie (Rooney Mara); American Gangster-Eva (Lymari Nadal); Assassination of Jesse James-Zee James (Mary-Louise Parker); Badlands-Holly (Sissy Spacek); The Big Heat-Debby Marsh (Gloria Grahame); Bonnie & Clyde-Bonnie Parker (Faye Dunaway); Bugsy-Virginia Hill (Annette Bening); Butch Cassidy & Sundance Kid-Etta Place (Katharine Ross); Carlito’s Way-Gail (Penelope Ann Miller); Casino-Ginger McKenna (Sharon Stone); The Counselor-Malkina (Cameron Diaz); Desperado-Carolina (Salma Hayek); Dillinger-Billie Frechette (Michelle Phillips); Drive-Irene (Carey Mulligan); Fight Club-Marla Singer (Helena Bonham Carter); Gangs of New York-Jenny Everdeane (Cameron Diaz); The Godfather-Kay Corleone (Diane Keaton); Goodfellas-Karen Hill (Lorraine Bracco); Grosse Point Blank-Debi Newberry (Minnie Driver); Heat-Charlene Shiherlis (Ashley Judd); Heat-Eady (Amy Brenneman); The Hit-Maggie (Laura del Sol); Jackie Brown-Melanie Ralston (Bridget Fonda); Kalifornia-Adele Corners (Juliette Lewis); Killer Joe-Dottie Smith (Juno Temple); The Killers-Kitty Collins (Ava Gardner); The Long Good Friday-Victoria (Helen Miren); Miller’s Crossing-Verna (Marcia Gay Harden); Mystic River-Annabeth Markum (Laura Linney); Natural Born Killers-Mallory Knox (Juliette Lewis); The Newton Boys-Louise Brown (Julianna Margulies) Once Upon A Time in America-Carol (Tuesday Weld); Once Upon A Time in America-Deborah Gelly (Elizabeth McGovern); Pulp Fiction-Mia Wallace (Uma Thurman); Public Enemies-Billie Frechette (Marion Cotillard); Road to Perdition-Annie Sullivan (Jennifer Jason Leigh); Scarface-Elvira Hancock (Michelle Pfeiffer); Straight Time-Jenny Mercer (Theresa Russell); True Romance-Alabama Whitman (Patricia Arquette); White Heat-Verna Jarrett (Virginia Mayo)